California's decision in 1996 to outlaw the use of race in public college admissions was widely viewed as the beginning of the end for affirmative action at public universities all over the United States. But in the four years since Californians passed Proposition 209, most states have agreed that killing affirmative action outright would deepen social inequality by denying minority citizens access to higher education. The half-dozen states that are actually thinking about abandoning race-sensitive
admissions policies are themselves finding that the only way to enlarge the minority presence in college without such policies is to improve dramatically the public schools that most black and Latino students attend.
As a result, these states are keeping a close eye on California, Texas and Florida, where "percentage systems" have sprung up to replace affirmative action. Under these systems, students who achieve a specified ranking in their high school graduating
classes are guaranteed admission to state colleges.
In California, for example, the so-called 4 percent plan guarantees college admission to everyone in the top 4 percent of high school graduating classes statewide. Minority enrollment, which crashed after Proposition 209 passed, has rebounded at the
second-tier colleges. But the decline has continued at the flagship colleges, U.C.L.A. and Berkeley -- largely because the high schools in black and Latino neighborhoods routinely fail to offer the advanced placement courses that are readily available in
white neighborhoods and that are taken into account when the elite colleges make admissions decisions.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Southern California has challenged this arrangement in a class-action lawsuit. Having eliminated the race-sensitive policies that once compensated for these inequalities, California is now being forced to deal with
the inferior public schools that made those policies necessary.
The University of Texas has learned a similar lesson since a federal court ruling forced it to abandon race-based admissions policies in 1996. Black and Latino enrollment dipped precipitously in the first year, but rose again after the legislature passed a
law guaranteeing college admission to all students who graduate in the ...
... middle of paper ...
...no children to fall behind.
Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida is currently embroiled in a fight over an executive order that outlaws race-based admissions at the state universities -- while guaranteeing admissions to the top 20 percent of high school classes. Mr. Bush's order was meant to render moot a ballot initiative on affirmative action that Republicans feared would heighten black turnout in this year's presidential election. The 20 percent rule seemed non-controversial and even generous -- until Governor Bush found that roughly two-thirds of additional black students who might benefit from the rule had been so neglected in high school that they had failed to graduate with the necessary credits for admission to the state university system. The state is now pushing public schools that serve black students to provide better course offerings.
What all these states have learned is that the only real way to make race-sensitive policies unnecessary is to guarantee black and Latino children from poor communities a realistic chance at a decent education that prepares them for college. To kill the policies before those guarantees are in place is to court civic disaster.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Between 1990 and 2012, high school graduation rates in 25-29-year-olds have increased from 86 to 90 percent; this overall national rise is reflected in each of the ethnicities, White, Hispanic, Black, and Asian/Pacific Islander (National Center for Education Statistics [NCES], 2013a). Prior to 2012, nationwide standardized objective measures did not exist for measuring four-year high school graduation rates; tracking educational progress varied from state to state. Thus, state education data collected from 1990-2012 are inaccurate as effective comparative groups unless knowledge of the state-specific previous methodologies is utilized (U.S.... [tags: social issues, race, ethnicity]
1372 words (3.9 pages)
- The utilization of race in affirmative action policies in higher education has been a topic of contention for several decades now. Since the passing of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, we have seen some of the most heated debates over the fairness of affirmative action and the impacts on society the utilization of race creates. With such pending questions on fairness and of the constitutionality of affirmative action policies two major Supreme Court cases have arisen, University of California Regents v.... [tags: critical race theory, diversity]
1238 words (3.5 pages)
- ... This system of segregation, also referred to as Jim Crow, was built out of an oppressive system of slavery and according to Freire (2000), simply duplicated the same system, leaving white supremacy to shape reality, society and culture. Within this system of segregation, the superior white race still received special privileges and protections that people of color did not. Segregation simply ensured separate facilities for separate races. This somehow made everything equal. White became a standard that everything else had to be substandard to.... [tags: Racism, White people, Sociology, Race]
1465 words (4.2 pages)
- ... However, De facto segregation still occurs now without being being enforced by the government but results from social and economic conditions. In schools and neighborhoods today, the segregation still exists. The hindrance of further improvements of race relations in the United States is the tendency to live in separate neighborhoods. White Americans have accepted African Americans advancement to equality as long as they do not move next door (Meyer 62). Even though these laws were a stepping stone towards equality, in the present day in varying degrees, discrimination can be seen in neighborhoods, schools and mortgage discrimination (Meyer 64).... [tags: Racism, African American, Discrimination]
1078 words (3.1 pages)
- “I hope that people will finally come to realize that there is only one race, the human race and that we are all members of it.” (Margaret Atwood) Since the beginning of the US history until now, racism has been a problem in the United States. Even though there have been emblematic struggles, it has not ceased to be something present in society. Racism has been very influential in society. For many years, it determined whether a person could be part of a specific group. According to the Dictionary of Human Geography, “Any act that links tendencies, affinities, behaviors or characteristics to an individual or community based on innate, indelible or physiological attributes, intended or not, i... [tags: African American, United States, Race]
1577 words (4.5 pages)
- Born With Opportunity High school students are intimidated due to the tuition of colleges and universities, so a plethora of the students resort to community college that they may have the chance they deserve to receive a college education. Young adults are looking for scholarships or financial aid, but there is not enough opportunity, except for the students that receive the race-based scholarships. The people that apply tend to have false hope because they need something that they may not receive.... [tags: High school, College, Higher education, University]
1516 words (4.3 pages)
- ... The purpose of this study is to create an awareness of racism and oppression using the personal experience of Richard Wright in his autobiography Black Boy. Our intention to show that racism and oppression is a prominent theme in Black Boy especially because the book was written in the Jim Crow era at a point where racism was very prominent in American Society. It also looks at the personal understanding of the black man’s point of view. Examples of racism and oppression are all through Black Boy.... [tags: Race, White people, Black people]
1064 words (3 pages)
- ... 2.) Color-blindness is impractical because there are so many other racial markers, outside of the color of someones skin. “Race affects every aspect of a person that cannot be ignored: Zip codes, clothing, voice, and even names carry racial markings” (Pg. 212). This was proven through a study done by two economists in Chicago and Boston. “...using almost 5,000 resumes with either a traditionally White name (like Emily or Greg) or traditionally African American one (like LaToya or Jamal). They found a 50 percent gap in call-back rates favoring the White names, with a White name yielding as many more call-backs as an additional eight years of work experience” (Pg 212).... [tags: Racism, White people, Race, Race]
1047 words (3 pages)
- When Europeans arrived in the America, they encountered people whom they had never before seen. The natives were viewed as savage and uncivilized, regardless of their well-established culture and presence. As the colonies formed and Africans began their slave-bound voyages to America, many colonists perceived them as inferior. Eurocentrism allowed for a foundation on which the race concept was built and flourished. As research shows, there is only one species of human beings, Homo sapiens. “Race,” used as a construct to stratify societies, is not a reference to biological variation.... [tags: Anthropology, Discrimination, Eurocentrism]
2239 words (6.4 pages)
- In this day and age, the United States, leader of the free world, is not leading. Our economic system is failing. Even worse, our educational system falls short compared to other nations. Consequently, our literacy rate and mathematical abilities are far behind; and even more embarrassing is the fact that education is not doled out equally despite our rather relentless fight against inequality. When academic achievement is examined on the basis of race, class, and gender, widening academic gaps are evident.... [tags: Education, Curriculum]
2558 words (7.3 pages)