Medical Technology and the Separation of Man's Body and Mind

Medical Technology and the Separation of Man's Body and Mind

Length: 2416 words (6.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Medical Technology and the Separation of Man's Body and Mind

The human was once whole in days before, but somewhere in his journey to the present, he lost himself. His mind and body have become separate identities that are unaware of each other's existence. Modern society reflects and encourages those thoughts very well, in my opinion. If a person believes his body is broken, ill, or in need of upgrading, he will seek out a medical professional specialized in the area of distress. Arriving to the specialist, the patient demands quick and efficient treatments that will cure/fix/upgrade the weakness in his body; unaware of the effects this may cause him mentally. Once cured of his weakness, the patient is in full working order and is sent back out into the world. That man's procedure for curing his weakness is the same road taken as someone who wishes to fix a toaster, for example. Would it then be safe to say that the man, subconsciously or consciously, considers his body to be more closely related to a tool rather than a part of himself? Unfortunately, I believe this man is only one person out of an entire society that shares the same dissociation of body and mind. Why do people of modern society not associate themselves with their physical being, and where is this leading us? Moreover, how did this alienation of self come about? I will try to explain the latter of the two questions first, because I believe the answer can be explained through the evolution of medical technology.

Traditionally, the main goal of medicine, as in the practice of, has been to cure diseases and prevent death, a classic human vs. nature scenario. To overcome death, which is a part of all the life cycles in the natural world, is virtually impossible. However, I am not here to argue the validity of man's fight with nature. I am trying to explain that the traditional medical community has but one enemy, and its success with that enemy has been limited. However, as time passes, the main goals of medicine start to become questionable. Daniel Callahan addresses some of modern medicines new goals in the fifth chapter of False Hopes. Describing the second great attraction of modern medicine, he writes:

Here the aim is not the historical goal of avoiding disease and averting death, but of using the knowledge

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Medical Technology and the Separation of Man's Body and Mind." 23 Jan 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Technology in the Modern Medical Office Essays

- A small medical office of four doctors and support staff decides they want to set up a wireless LAN to let them to take their laptops with them from room to room for real-time data entry on patient records. The doctors know they need to comply with HIPPA controls over patient records and are concerned that a Wi-Fi LAN could compromise security. The intent of this paper is to offer advice to the medical office manager about the implementation of a Wi-Fi access point for their network. I will cover the elements needed within a policy, and the development of a high-level standard that will address the considerations for implementing Wi-Fi under HIPPA security rule constraints....   [tags: Medical Technology]

Research Papers
1725 words (4.9 pages)

Medical Technology During World War I Essay

- Surgeries at the time of WWI were a direct result of the Industrial Revolution’s new technology; these surgical advances struggled to fix the horrible injuries sustained by soldiers from the new sophisticated weaponry. "Every war stimulates medical research. It’s sad, but true," said Frank Freemon. Although many soldiers died during attempts at things like reconstructive surgery and Caesarian sections, experimenting in the surgical fields improved conditions and advanced the science, as well as develop new professions in surgery....   [tags: Medical Technology]

Research Papers
905 words (2.6 pages)

Technology Is Changing the Mind Essay

- The clock is ticking, the work is piling up, and with only a few hours to go before sunrise you stop and realize that you have just read some fifty pages and absorbed almost nothing. Some would agree when I say that this situation epitomizes one of the common problems of the Net Generation. With the help of the Internet, not only has every aspect of life gotten faster and more efficient, but it has changed the way people process information and perform tasks. In addition, while technology does have its benefits, the extensive use of the internet is affecting the way people think....   [tags: Technology ]

Research Papers
1410 words (4 pages)

Essay about Companies and Technology in the Medical Field

- In United States medical care, the instrumentation and supply industry forms a focal unit in ensuring that the field is well equipped to deal with the ever growing medical requirements for both, the people living in and out of the country. Medical device companies produce a massive amount of products used for diagnosing and treating ailments. These incorporate surgical and professional medical instruments, electromedical, and also electrotherapeutic apparatuses, precise appliances and materials, ophthalmic goods, and clinical equipment (Scannell 2004)....   [tags: medical care, accuracy inc, medical devices ]

Research Papers
937 words (2.7 pages)

The Effects Of Technology On The Human Mind Essay

- Technological advancement has in many ways benefited human society as a whole, and humanity shows no signs of slowing down. However, even though all this new technology has had a beneficial growth on the world and ways words cannot describe, the greatest impact being on the human mind. More specifically and dangerously the minds of the growing youth. Technology has done nothing but make communication easier for people, especially through the invention of the smartphone. Society ignores the social and emotional development of the mind due to this new technology, which can be connected to stress, loneliness, and inattentiveness....   [tags: Mobile phone, Adolescence, Internet, Technology]

Research Papers
1148 words (3.3 pages)

How Technology Is Medical Training Essay

- ... “Simulation-based learning can be the way to develop health professionals’ knowledge, skills, and attitudes, whilst protecting patients from unnecessary risks” (Lateef, 2010 ¶1). Consequently, students can be in charge of a simulated patient encounter, run a simulated cardiac arrest, or even perform invasive skills without the fear of causing any harm. Tradition vs. Technology Tradition has long been a driving force behind the structure of modern medical training. A surgeon remembers her residency this way, “We were learning as generations of doctors before us had – under the supervision of more experienced doctors, through trial and error, and on real patients…this old paradigm of sinki...   [tags: Physician, Medical school, Medicine]

Research Papers
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Transgender Surgery and the Separation Between Mind and Body

- Is there a distinction between the mind and the body. And if so, where does a person’s sense of self and consciousness lay. If consciousness lies within the mind, how should humans’ treat the body, as valuable or invaluable. According to dualist views there is a separation between the mind and the body that transgender patients feel every day. Imagine the pain and frustration one might feel when the people around look at you and think you should act and dress one way but you feel differently. That is the frustration transgendered people feel daily....   [tags: gender, LGBTQ, Bruce Jenner]

Research Papers
2512 words (7.2 pages)

Essay on Ethical Issues in Medical Technology

- Advancements in medical technology are made every day. Diseases are being cured, and better treatments are becoming available for the diseases that are not. As a result, people are living longer, and some medical problems that once killed, now do not. Almost anyone would agree that living longer would be great, but for patients’ suffering from dementia, Alzheimer’s, or any other debilitating disease, a longer life is just more time to suffer. Prolonged life has become a topic of ethical debate, and there are many things to be considered when discussing it....   [tags: diseases, treatment, life-extending technology]

Research Papers
1220 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Importance of Radiological Technology

- When you hear the word radiology, what comes to mind. Do you think of the overbearing effects that radiation can have on the body or perhaps the remarkable usage that comes from it's technology. Most people don't realize how extremely helpful radiation can be, but seldom it can be dreadful. The medical field would not be as productive without the use of radiological technologies. When I say dreadful I mean the damaging consequences on the body that can come from radiation. Technicians who work around radiological equipment, such as -x-ray, CT or even mammograms, usually aren't too exposed to radiation because even though its every day, it's only for a short period of time....   [tags: Medical Technology ]

Research Papers
1585 words (4.5 pages)

Medical Technology Essay

- What is medical technology. Medical technology is procedures, equipment, and processes by which medical care is delivered. It is also any scientific discovery that finds its application in delivering health care. As technology advances the ability of providers to diagnose, treat and prevent health problems also increase, as stated by the Congressional Budget Office “the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) defines technological advances broadly to include any changes in clinical practice that enhance the ability of providers to diagnose, treat, or prevent health problems.” (CBO)....   [tags: Healthcare, Technology]

Research Papers
1342 words (3.8 pages)

Related Searches

and skills of medicine to satisfy our personal desire for the transcendence of fate: for control of procreation and a more perfect baby; for better athletic performance; for reduction in the ordinary stresses of life; for a more attractive face and body; for a happier, more relaxed personality or mood; for a more competitive height. (140)

The traditional local doctor, with his home remedies, has become outdated, and his patients feel more secure going to see the new high-tech specialist. Medicine has since then become synonymous with technology. This shift in tradition to technology is a characteristic of what Jacques Ellul calls the "Technical Phenomenon" (19). A brief definition of the "Technical Phenomenon" could be: all common points, tendencies, and principles that are shared by all techniques. In particular, I am referring to the tendency of today's society to pursue the "one best way" which is equal to the quickest and most efficient way.

In the medical profession, this becomes evident when one observes the way a doctor treats his patient. If the doctor is considered professional, he will summon a patient with the usual cry, "Next," and then proceed to diagnose and fix the problem as quickly and efficient as possible. The patient is then sent back out into the world, but I am sure this cycle sounds familiar. I think Alvin Weinberg would call this cycle a temporary "Technological Fix" (Thompson 42). This means someone uses technology, in the technical sense, to solve the current problem, but the source of that problem remains unchecked. I believe that many patients look for those "quick technological fixes" because that is what society has started to expect from the medical community. David Morris writes, "Many people take comfort in thinking about the body as a machine that requires merely an occasional trip to the repair shop: the analogy allows us to postpone troublesome questions about illness because we assume that the medical profession will know exactly what to do when an emergency arises" (14).

The false assumption of what the medical community is capable of is an excellent example of how alienation of self came about in this particular field. Society has passed down a false consciousness that would, supposedly, make people feel safer going about their environment, but this assumption has caused a severe side-effect: the dissociation of man's physical body and his conscious mind. The majority feels like they can do whatever they want to their bodies and it will not effect them as a person, because if anything were to go wrong the doctors could fix it. Americans feel they should look toward medical technology to find a miracle cure for obesity, rather than cut back on the fast food restaurants and snack machines that haunt every corner of their cities. Now, the slow realization of the alienation becomes evident in modern society. Moreover, this false assumption of medicine will continue to grow as technology progresses, but what are some of the reasons that society finds appealing about this dehumanizing attitude?

The most historical reason for separating mind from body is to make the perfect "utopian body" (Morris 136). Many look toward medical technology to create what Morris calls "a paradise of curves and muscles" (137). Steroids, diet drugs, and cosmetic surgery are the quickest routes to the "utopian body," but the side effects of those are not good for the body and society is aware of that but still uses them anyway. Morris points out a good example of the alienation of physical self when he writes about how people in a postmodern culture regard their bodies as malleable tools. He further states, "The colossal, godlike figures celebrated in Renaissance sculpture and painting, utopian bodies in the postmodern era are disengaged from any discourse about mind or spirit" (137). Around 1990, the most frequently performed surgery was liposuction, the process of vacuuming fat cells from beneath the skin, and coming in a close second were breast implants and facelifts (Morris 140). These manipulations of the body reflect what society thought beauty should be at the time. Morris comments on the difference between bodybuilders and powerlifters when he writes, "These [bodybuilder] competitions do not measure strength. Powerlifters compete to demonstrate strength, whereas bodybuilders create their muscles solely for display." Still, what is accomplished by having a person achieve in building the "utopian body"? Is the satisfaction of meeting one of society's goal worth the mental and physical damage of drugs and surgery, not to mention the large waste of time from weightlifting?

For the sake of efficiency is another reason for separating mind and body. To live at the physical constraints of the human body would be very inefficient by today's standards. Human limitations in areas such as pain tolerance and the biological sleep cycle, which were once considered completely natural, are starting to be viewed by modern society as flaws in the body. If a person is in pain, a common symptom of the overworked, then they cannot perform at their optimum whether at home or work. That is why pain relievers stock shelves at gas stations, grocery stores, and superstores such as Walmart. People choose quick and effective ways of getting rid of common colds and aches instead of trying to go ahead and let the body fight the cold. The very thought that the body can heal itself has become somewhat laughable in modern society. Unfortunately, the notion of resting until a full recovery is also a notion that modern society has trouble with. Everyone is on the go and has to be places. Therefore, if pain is affecting a person's job, then he should just pop a couple of pills and get back to work, or that is the way modern society wishes us to believe. If the mind does not register the pain the body is in, then everything must be okay. The pain will probably be doubled once the pain reliever wears off, but, when that happens, the person can just take more pills and repeat.

Pain relievers are not the only drugs people use to increase their productivity. Stimulants are being made for those who wish to stay awake for several days. Disregard the incredibly harmful side effects of not sleeping, the pros of the drug outweigh the cons in today's technical society. The ability to stay awake for days at a time will lead to incredible productivity for companies. Another drugs that reflect modern society are the sexual enhancing drugs. The body, which may have stopped working naturally, is being forced to work/perform by a chemical that is circulating throughout the blood stream. This forced labor brings about the image of the body being a slave/tool of the mind, but I am not sure how long a body can be forced to perform before it crashes.

The goals of modern society are encouraging the shift into separate identities. I believe that the goals of society, such as the pursuit of an efficient "utopian body," guide the evolution of man and how he looks at himself. Therefore, man's evolution of values and ethics is directly related to the transformation of his society around him. I know this is a quick and rough theory, but it becomes evident upon closer inspection. Jeremy Rifken writes about this shift in society. He refers to the new up and coming age as the "Age of Access," which has values many people are starting to adopt. Rifken writes, "Just as the printing press altered human consciousness over the past several hundred years, the computer will likely have a similar affect on consciousness over the next two centuries" (12). This leads to the question: Why am I writing about how man evolves with society? To properly think and predict how man's values, such as his view of his body and mind, evolve, one must understand the process of evolution. Once an understanding has been reached, I can carry on with a question I asked earlier: Where will the dissociation of man's physical body and conscious mind lead society? If my understanding of how man evolves is correct, then it shall show through the accuracy of my predictions.

The future of society is one I cannot predict, but if it is heading in the same route as today, then educated guesses become acceptable. Today society is heading towards a technological state, and we are not only heading toward it, we are embracing it, too. False consciousness about notions such as "progress" and the "neutrality of technology" are masking the actual nature of the beast known as technology. Using Ellul's theory on the "Technical Phenomenon," I can say that the alienation of body and mind will become more extreme as time progresses (325). Medical technology will conquer the ethical limits of modern society, and a new race of genetically perfect machines, known as the human body, will become another advertisement on everyone's high definition television. Unlike the health and surgery advertisements of today, it will become possible for people to go out and replace their bodies with the latest and greatest upgraded models, in the same way computers are today. Bodies that will not get tired, sick, or age and come with a five-year warranty will become the norm. Stores that sell used computers today may end up selling used human bodies tomorrow.

In addition, parents will have options when it comes to designing their sons in the same way that Best Buy creates individual computer packages for its customers. Parents will be able to choose their son's or daughter's personality with the click of a button. "How smart do you want to make your son?" Click. "How funny do you want to make your son?" Click. "Thank you, your total comes to $12,000.99, and your baby will be delivered to your door in six to eight weeks."

Of course, I am only writing about the absolute extremes society will, hopefully, never reach, but the slightest notion that we could achieve such cold dehumanizing efficiency is frightening. My predictions will probably never become a reality, but if they do, no one will really care what I am writing about in this paper. The realization of the separation of man's physical body and conscious mind is the first step in fixing what I believe is a problem. Modern society, however, will disagree with me and argue that there are no problems today that technology and progress cannot fix. The realization that technology and progress are what have caused many of today's problems may also help bring about a cure, but it is unlikely. The solution to fixing a person's false consciousness lies in changing society for the better, but what is considered to be better is beyond my judgment. Moreover, the process of transforming society for the better is lost on me. Normally, people look towards technology to find a solution to society's problems, but where do we look to find a solution to the technology problem? Maybe the problem has no cure and we're doomed to live out the consequences of our creation. Technology has saved us from a life of discomfort, and now it enslaves us in a web of efficiency and productivity. Thinkers such as Ellul and Langdon Winner would agree with me. Then again, perhaps I am wrong and there really is no problem; it is "all in my head." Whatever course taken will not be decided by man, and only time can foresee which course is taken.

Works Cited

Callahan, Daniel. False Hopes. New York: Simon & Schuster, inc., 1 998.

Ellul, Jaques. The Technological Society. Trans. John Wilkinson. Toronto: Random House, 1964.

Golub, Edward. The Limits of Medicine. New York: Time Books, 1994.

Horrobin, David. Medical Hubris: A Reply to Ivan Illich. Montreal: Eden Press, n.d.

Morris, David. Illness and Culture in the Postmodern Age. California: University of California Press, 1998.

Rifken, Jeremy. The Age of Access. New York: Penguin Putnam Inc., 2000.

Thompson, William, Ed. Controlling Technology. New York: Prometheus Books, 1991.

Vaux, Kenneth, Ed. Powers That Make Us Human: The Foundations of Medical Ethics. Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1985.
Return to