Lawsuits and the End of Sanity in America

Lawsuits and the End of Sanity in America

Length: 991 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Lawsuits and the End of Sanity in America

Not having experienced much of the past is a mixed blessing. What's grotesque, shocking and unheard of to older Americans might seem normal, perhaps just a bit curious, to younger Americans. For example, last year New Orleans Mayor Marc Morial brought suit against gun manufacturers to recover carnage costs in his city. This January, Philadelphia Mayor Ed Rendell met with his advisors to consider whether the City should sue gun manufacturers for creating a public nuisance since guns were used in Philadelphia's 400-plus homicides. The City would seek to recover the cost of everything from cleaning up after bloody murders to the costs of court and social workers for victims. Mayor Rendell's imagination has also led him to discover a new liability for tobacco companies: since some of Philadelphia's fires have careless smoking as their origin, why not sue tobacco companies to recover the city's fire losses?

Decades ago anyone suggesting bringing lawsuits against gun manufacturers for homicides, or tobacco companies for fires caused by careless smoking would have been considered a prime candidate for a lunatic asylum. If one generalizes from the lawsuits brought against gun manufacturers because people use their product to commit murder and mayhem, and against tobacco companies for smoking illnesses and fires caused by careless smoking, he would conclude that people are not to be held responsible for anything they do. It is the inanimate object, while incapable of acting, that is responsible. That is, a gun is responsible for murder, not the gun's user. A cigarette is responsible for a fire, not the careless smoker. That being the case, it "logically" follows that manufacturers of the offending inanimate object are culpable. After all had the manufacture not produced the gun or cigarette there would be fewer homicides, smoking-related illnesses and fires caused by careless smoking.

This it's-not-my-fault principle could be broadened to include just about anything. If a scantily clad young lady is prancing along the street, distracts my attention, and I have an automobile collision, the it's-not-my-fault principle would hold the young lady liable for my accident. But she might make the case that it is the manufacturer of her mini-skirt who is really liable. If we Americans were to carry the it's-not-my-fault principle to its logical conclusion, we would virtually guarantee poverty. There would be little production. Why should I manufacture irons if I could be held liable for anything a person might do with the iron, including assault or leaving the iron unattended thereby causing a fire.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Lawsuits and the End of Sanity in America." 23 Jan 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

We Must Put an End to Frivolous Inmate Lawsuits Essay

- We Must Put an End to Frivolous Inmate Lawsuits Our forefathers were bright enough to establish a system of government with a series of checks and balances to maintain a balanced government. For the past decade a series of checks and balances has begun to fail our government. In our failing system of government inmates have taken advantage of the court system and have flooded it with an inconceivable number of frivolous lawsuits. Laurel Walters, a writer for the Christian Science Monitor, investigated inmates' lawsuits and found that these "recreational litigators...are suing the courts as an intramural sports activity." Action needs to be taken in order to rectify and protect "US" from th...   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]

Research Papers
1469 words (4.2 pages)

Sanity and Substance Essay

- America is said to be one of the most advanced countries in the world. But the people living in it are far from advanced. Millions of Americans are not happy, they either become depressed because of material things, become addicted to substances you receive for being crazy, or are forced to be classified as insane or ‘special’. Over the course of 12 months, Americans have a 27% chance of having some sort of ‘mental disorder’ whether it is a personality disorder, eating disorder, anxiety disorder, and/or mood disorder....   [tags: America, Mental Disorders]

Research Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

Obesity Lawsuits by Nancy Hall Essay

- In Nancy Hall's "Obesity Lawsuits" (2004) essay, Hall is determined to address the problem constantly growing and silently taking lives in America every day, obesity. The author goes on to argue that people should not be suing "fast food companies" (Hall, 2004, p. 113), but rather look at themselves to blame for becoming obese. Americans need to think about their own decisions routinely, exercise to keep the extra weight off and choose meals that are healthier (Hall, 2004). The authors thesis states: "Listening to the subtle nuance emerging from legal debate, we can hear a discernable message that clearly spells out the desperate need for further study, public awareness, and education on obe...   [tags: Analysis, Nancy Hall]

Research Papers
1200 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Lawsuits Involving Social Media

- Facebook is a social network that lets you post anything you want, like; statuses, pictures, videos. You can see what your friends are doing just by what they post and they can do the same for you. Twitter is about the same when it comes to sharing posts, pictures, etc. but you have a limit of characters for each tweet you send.. These social networks take over a persons’ life because of how much they are on it; but this is only one of few major problems with that come with these networks....   [tags: cyberbullying, invasion of privacy]

Research Papers
1046 words (3 pages)

For My Sanity Essay

- ... Elise: 30, 31 me: was largely borrowed from Wright & Butler just written better Elise: then 33-35; 37-41 me: the next paragraph was ripped from my brain and requires you borrow some basic transaction-cost economics 37 was a footnote from one of the cites you sent me Elise: 42-46; (of which i know two are given, but i started skipping the section as i got stressed out) me: I hear you Elise: 47-53 me: so basically there's like 20 of those that aren't done ok Elise: and 55 (which i know i have just haven't done) and then everything from 94 on that need to be done me: bc your cites pick up at 101 Elise: yes but there are a significant amount to fill in that section also...   [tags: personal narrative]

Research Papers
675 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Pincher Martin: No Sanity When You'Re Stranded

- Pincher Martin: No Sanity When You're Stranded In the novel, Pincher Martin, written by William Golding, Christopher Hadley Martin goes through a psychological transformation when he is stranded on an uninhabited island. The author associates his internal change with external change, by forcing Christopher into isolation and with the use of strong symbolic language. This seclusion triggers his transformation and ultimately results in his death. Christopher begins his journey when he is the only survivor of a torpedoed destroyer during World War II....   [tags: Pincher Martin Sanity Stranded]

Free Essays
1391 words (4 pages)

The End of Affluence by Jeffery Madrick Essay examples

- The End of Affluence by Jeffery Madrick      As the first European settlers arrived in America, ideas of wealth and prosperity were fully implanted in their minds. These ideas soon turned into reality, and the United States dominated the global economy up until the post World War II years. In this paper, from the Book The End of Affluence by Jeffery Madrick, we will discuss how America has gone from domination of the economic market , to just barely hanging on, and the many roads both good and bad that it took....   [tags: Economics End Affluence Madrick Essays]

Free Essays
3959 words (11.3 pages)

Essay on Frivolous Lawsuits

- Justice, Tranquility and The Greed for Money Lynn Hubbard is handicapped. She happens to also have her own law firm. In the past year, she sued more than 600 nearly irreproachable institutions for over two million dollars. Hubbard and her entourage of scheming lawyers have not done anything illegal. Some may argue that she has simply exercised her right to the legal system. In any case, Hubbard is part of the growing American society that has discovered large money in mass litigation. This rise in greedy and manipulative lawyers has provided Americans with a skewed financial interest in the American courtroom and has hindered the justice system as a whole....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Research Papers
2348 words (6.7 pages)

Petty Lawsuits Essay

- Are we Sueing for a Purpose. People today are not sueing to rectify matters. There is no purpose in lawsuits today. I believe everyone is out to get an easy buck through the judicial system. It is almost inevitable if people spill hot coffee on themselves that they will win a lawsuit against the company that served them that coffee. People believe that nothing is their fault and that someone (the defendant) should pay. The problem with the judicial system today is that people are sueing all the time and winning in court with ridiculous cases....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
752 words (2.1 pages)

Sanity Essay

- Sanity, as it is often defined, is the condition in which one is considered mentally sound. This, stems questions relating to what is mentality, and of course, what is healthy. Many believe that the human mind is subjugated into several distinctive sections; the sensual, affection, moral, intellectual, and spiritual elements. In every department there exists a power that rules the predispositions of the mind, which we know as reason. To maintain sanity through reason, two things are required. First, the harmonious working of all the elements of mind, and second, the ability to analyse and differentiate between the separate components....   [tags: sane, mentally healthy]

Free Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Related Searches

Suppose by some miracle a person who died as recently as 1950 was to come back to visit today's America, how might we explain all of this to him. At first blush we might tell him that Americans and their leaders have taken complete leave of their senses and wish to abandon all notions of personal responsibility. But there is a more flattering alternative explanation nonetheless still troubling: Americans simply want other people's money and the courts and the legislature have provided them with a mechanism for doing so. I do not believe we have reached a point where the courts would countenance legislatures brazenly picking out a corporation and saying, "You look as if you have a lot of money; give it to us." Thus, we have to create an aura of legitimacy to extortion. We create that aura of legitimacy by propaganda impugning the company's moral character and create bogus science. Health and professed concern about the nation's children have been two successful strategies. After all who can be against health and the welfare of America's children?

Where it all ends is difficult to predict but there are some signs on the horizon. "Caffeine is the new drug of choice among kids." warns Helen Cordes writing in Nation magazine (4/27/98), adding, "Caffeine Inc., [soda manufacturers] is raking it in, often targeting teens and younger kids. . . . The major caffeine suppliers to kids have been throwing millions into advertising and give-aways." The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) agrees and wants the FDA to regulate caffeine content in soda, coffee, tea and chocolate. Michael Jacobson, CSPI's director, also thinks Mexican and Chinese restaurants offer servings much too large and says, "It's high time the [restaurant] industry begins to bear some responsibility for its contribution to obesity, heart disease and cancer." Since obesity impacts heavily on healthcare costs, why not bring lawsuits against the food industry like those against the tobacco industry? Yale University's Professor Kelley D. Brownell, director of the Center for Eating & Weight Disorders, proposes that fatty foods and those with little nutritional content be taxed. Professor Brownell recommends that the tax proceeds be used to build bike and hiking trails. He also says that since the average child sees 10,000 food commercials each year, 95 percent of them for junk food and sugared cereals, Congress ought to regulate junk food commercials. After all the cigarette tyrants got "Joe Camel" advertisements banned, why go after Rice Krispies "snap, crackle and pop"?

In New York city there's a group calling itself the Anti-Dairy Coalition. Its Executive Director Robert Cohen, author of the book "Milk, The Deadly Poison" says, "Milk products, like tobacco, are an enormous threat to the health of both children and adults, yet we see the dairy industry protected by constitutionally questionable laws while the tobacco industry is held accountable."

Dr. Ronald Griffiths, at Johns Hopkins University, is concerned about coffee's addictive qualities and says, "If health risks are well-documented, caffeine could be catapulted in public perception from a pleasant habit to a possibly harmful drug of abuse." That vision, along with bogus science, might become justification for lawsuits and FDA regulation of coffee and chocolate caffeine content.

If there is a blessing to being an age when one contemplates the arrival of the grim reaper, it is the knowledge that he will not be around for the end of sanity in America.
Return to